I was watching The View today (ouch!) and the topic of Princess Beatrice and her size “normal” body came up (doesn’t Beatrice look great here!). Everyone on the panel lamented the pitiful state of media images and declared that, as women, we need to quit buying into the whole thing. Then Whoopi quoted a study in which 56% of women reported that they would rather have cancer than be fat. Joy Behar kept commenting on how “sick” that attitude is and how warped our cultural notions are around fat and body image. Yet, in the same breath, she mentioned that she was going to an acupuncturist that same afternoon to try to control her appetite, because if she didn’t quite eating she could get “bigger and bigger.” To her credit, she admitted:
Just because I criticize doesn’t mean I’m not a victim and a perpetrator.
This perfectly illustrates the results of the study in my previous post: even though women are better educated than ever on the myth of the thin ideal, we buy into the message even more so than a decade ago.
You can see the segment in it’s entirety at http://abc.go.com/daytime/theview/index, Hot Topics 5/7 - Healthy Women. (Be patient: the quote above occurs at the end of Part 3.)
If you watch this segment, or if you’ve already seen it, I would love your take on Whoopi’s statement at the end of the topic on body image and dieting. Whoopi is/was the spokesperson for a weight loss program, and her current diet is a regular feature on The View. What did she mean when she said that she didn’t care about her weight until someone talked to her about getting paid? Is she saying that the only reason she diets is for money? I didn’t get it.
One Response for "Unrealistic body image - victims and perpetrators"
I really think that’s the only reason any celebrity touts any diet like Jenny Craig, Weight Watchers, Nutrasystem, et al. Money talks, and if you pay them enough, they’ll say whatever the diet company wants them to say, whether they believe it or not, whether they actually follow the diet or not. Color me cynical, but that’s my opinion. That’s why I have absolutely no respect for any celebrity that starts talking about a diet and their health in the same breath. I do believe that saying those companies have a healthy diet is perpetuating a dangerous myth.
Leave a reply